| The
U.S. presidential election of 1948 is best known
as one of the greatest political upsets in history,
as incumbent President Harry S Truman defeated Republican
Thomas Dewey against the predictions of most contemporary
polls and in spite of a three-way split in his own
Democratic party.
Nominations
Republican Party nomination
In gearing up for the election of 1948, both major
parties courted General Dwight Eisenhower, a popular
war hero and political moderate who could carry
a large number of votes on the back of his military
record alone. However, Eisenhower refused, so
the Republicans chose Thomas E. Dewey, the Governor
of New York and a veteran of the previous presidential
election of 1944. Dewey had performed surprisingly
well against the popular FDR in wartime, so he
was expected to easily beat the unpopular Truman.
Progressive Party nomination
The Progressive Party reinvented itself in 1948
with the nomination of Henry Wallace, a former
Secretary of Agriculture and Vice President under
Franklin D. Roosevelt. Briefly Harry Truman's
secretary of commerce, he was fired for opposing
Truman's firm stand against the Soviet Union.
Wallace's 1948 platform opposed the Cold War,
the Marshall Plan and big business. He also campaigned
to end discrimination against blacks and women,
backed a minimum wage and called for the elimination
of the House Committee on Un-American Activities.
Democratic Party nomination
On July 12, the Democratic National Convention
convened in Philadelphia (in the same hall in
which the Republicans had nominated Dewey). Spirits
were low: the Republicans had taken control of
both houses of Congress and a majority of state
governorships during the 1946 midterm elections
by running against Truman, and his administration
did not seem to have become more popular. Indeed,
left-leaning Democrats had already split off to
revive the Progressive Party and nominate Henry
Wallace. Morale sank even further when some three
dozen Southern delegates, led by Strom Thurmond,
walked out of the convention in response to an
announcement by Truman that his platform would
advocate the passage of civil rights laws. Nonetheless,
the dispirited Democrats nominated the incumbent
President as their candidate by July 14th.
Dixiecrat Party nomination
The Democratic delegates who had bolted the Democratic
convention over Truman's civil rights platform
formed a separate party, which they named the
States Rights Party. More commonly known as the
"Dixiecrats", the party's main goal
was continuing racial segregation and the Jim
Crow laws which sustained it. South Carolina Governor
Strom Thurmond, who had led the walkout, became
the party's presidential nominee.
General election
Campaign
Given Truman's sinking popularity, Dewey seemed
unstoppable. The Republicans figured that all
they had to do was avoid any major missteps, and
as such, Dewey didn't take risks. He spoke in
platitudes, trying to transcend politics. Speech
after speech was filled with empty statements
of the obvious, such as the famous quote: "You
know that your future is still ahead of you."
An editorial in the Louisville Courier-Journal
summed it up best: "No presidential candidate
in the future will be so inept that four of his
major speeches can be boiled down to these historic
four sentences: Agriculture is important. Our
rivers are full of fish. You cannot have freedom
without liberty. Our future lies ahead."
[1]
Truman, on the other hand,
decided to pull the gloves off, targeting the
Republican-controlled 80th Congress. The 80th
Congress, led by Senator Robert A. Taft of Ohio,
was much more conservative than Dewey, and was
fixated on rolling back Roosevelt's New Deal.
However, under Dewey's leadership, the Republicans
enacted a platform at the 1948 convention which
called for expanding social security, more funding
for public housing, civil rights legislation,
and promotion of health and education by the federal
government.
President Harry S. Truman at the mic, left Harley
O. Staggers & Alben W. Barkley. 1948 in Keyser,
WV on Whistle Stop TourTruman exploited that rift
in the party by calling a special session on "Turnip
Day" (referring to an old Missouri folklore
about planting turnips in late July) to enact
legislation consistent with the Republican party's
platform. The 80th Congress played right into
Truman's hands, delivering very little in the
way of substantive legislation during this time.
From then on, Truman dubbed them the "Do-Nothing
Congress." Truman was able to ignore the
fact that Dewey's policies were liberal, and ran
against the conservative tendencies of the 80th
Congress.
Truman toured the nation
with this fiery rhetoric, playing to large, enthusiastic
crowds at every stop along the way. "Give
'em hell, Harry" was a popular slogan shouted
out at every stop along the tour. However, the
polls and the pundits all thought that Truman's
efforts were for naught, and pulled back from
reporting on the already-decided election.
Results
As expected, Thurmond's Dixiecrat party took away
much of the Democratic Party's traditional base
in the "Solid South", while Wallace
wooed away voters from the left wing of the Democratic
Party. However, Wallace's failure to repudiate
the endorsement of the Communist Party had undermined
his popularity, and he wound up with just over
2.4 percent of the popular vote. The Dixiecrats
held no attraction outside the South and got a
slightly smaller percentage of the popular vote.
Thus, despite the significant split in the Democratic
base, Truman won on November 2, surprising many
observers at the time. The Chicago Tribune had
gone so far as to print "DEWEY DEFEATS TRUMAN"
on election night as its headline for the following
day. A famous photograph shows Truman grinning
and holding up a copy of that newspaper with the
erroneous headline.
Truman's victory was entirely
due to his marginal wins in the large swing states
of Ohio, California, and Illinois, all three of
which he won by less than 1% and had a combined
total of 78 electoral votes, as well as a very
small victory in Idaho. Dewey countered by carrying
New York and Pennsylvania, the states with the
most electoral votes at the time, as well as Michigan,
but it wasn't enough to give him the election.
Thurmond carried four southern states, giving
him a handful of electoral votes, but not enough
to deny Truman the majority. Wallace won a nearly
identical percentage of the popular vote as Thurmond,
but failed to win a single electoral vote.
|